Solving Operation not Permitted Errors over Remote Access

June 18, 2021

Recently I purchased a 24” M1 iMac. One of my goals was to have a central place for all my digital content: movies, audiobooks, music, and photos. My venerable late-2013 MacBook Pro has a 1TB drive that cannot hold my entire collection along with my other files, applications, and the operating system.

For some time now I’ve been using an external USB drive to house my media. This drive has been plugged into an even more venerable 2009 MacBook Pro. The reason for using the much older laptop as host for my media is simple: that laptop doesn’t get moved. If the external drive were attached to my primary machine, I would constantly be moving it, with the laptop, or mounting and dismounting it.

With all my music, movies, and audiobooks offloaded to the external drive, there was enough room left on my primary laptop for all my photos, and the rest of my files. It wasn’t ideal, but it worked.

The new iMac has 256GB internal storage, and a pair of 4TB external drives. I have spent considerable time this past week consolidating all my digital media to one of the 4TB drives. I’ve also put my software projects directory, called code, there. When I am away from my desk and want to access something on the external drive on the iMac, those files are just an ssh connection away.

From the MacBook Pro I am using iTerm2 and ssh. From the iPadPro I’m using blink since it includes mosh, or mobile shell. The advantage to mosh is that the session stays in sync even if the connection is interrupted. Since iPadOS is fairly aggressive about stopping idle processes, using an ssh connection becomes tiresome as you are constantly having to reestablish it. With mosh, once you are connected you stay connected until you end the session.

I believe, though I am no longer certain, that the first remote session on my iMac was done from the iPadPro using mosh. On the iMac there is a component of mosh, mosh-server the runs and manages the incoming connection. This will play a key part in what happened with my ability to remotely access files over ssh/mosh.

MacOS allows you to control how your computer is shared. Under the Sharing preference pane in System Preferences, there is a Remote Login option. With that selected you can login to the local computer from a remote computer. Once Remote Login is enabled, there is a second option, Allow full disk access for remote users. This should be enough to permit ssh or mosh session access to any of the disks mounted.

In my case I was getting an Operation not permitted error any time I tried to access any external drive attached to the iMac. I got this error whether I used ssh or mosh, and from any remote device: iPadPro or MacBook Pro.

When the first remote login occurs a setting is added to Full Disk Access under the Security & Privacy Privacy pane. This setting is called sshd-keygen-wrapper. If it isn’t listed, or is listed and enabled, then full disk access is granted. If it is there and no enabled, however, full disk access is not granted. In my case, sshd-keygen-wrapper was present but not enabled.

I suspect that mosh (and mosh-server) having been the mechanism for the initial remote session, left the setting in a state where no remote access to external drives was allowed. Once I enabled that setting I was able to remotely access external drives using either ssh or mosh.

This Apple discussion thread, and the links it contains, do a better job of explaining the ins and outs of sshd-keygen-wrapper. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/250352651 I found this link through the ##apple IRC channel.

Author's profile picture

Mark H. Nichols

I am a husband, cellist, code prole, nerd, technologist, and all around good guy living and working in fly-over country. You should follow me on Twitter.